Skip to content

What do you use for spare parts inventory in single-location DC?

Datacenter Talk Locked by Chen 24 replies 3.2K views
This thread is locked — new replies are not accepted. (Closed: resolved)
#11
Fail1996 said:
40% mismatch on cables

Cables are a special case. Non-serialized, fungible, high-churn. SSDs have serial numbers, SMART data, finite wear. Different error regime.

Revised estimate: for serialized assets with barcode scan, spreadsheet error rate drops to 5-8% per my audit at last job. Still unacceptable for critical path, but "40% on everything" is misleading framing.

Raspberry Pi monitor: valid. I withdraw objection for <50 SKUs.

100% packet loss at hop 3
#12

I went and checked my "closet full of drives" after this thread. 14 drives, 3 are dead, I never marked them. Spreadsheet said 12 good, reality 11 good. Not 40% but not zero.

Amazon same-day is a lie in Phoenix summer, warehouse workers are human, I get it next day usually. I am switching to a simple Python script on an old laptop, reads a CSV, emails me when count < 2. Took 20 minutes. Fail1996 inspired me, thanks.

#13

Manchester here. I use eBuyer and Scan for next-day, or walk to their depot if desperate. For inventory I use Snipe-IT, self-hosted, overkill for some but I like the audit trail. Asset tags, the whole thing.

Single-location DC with no staff rotation? Maybe overkill. But I inherited 200 mystery boxes labeled "2018" and "???" so I am traumatized. Never again.

Honey badger don't care... about downtime
#14

In Berlin I use Reichelt and Conrad, both have will-call if I drive 30 minutes. For inventory I tried PartKeepr but it died, project abandoned. Now I use Home Assistant with a custom integration, scan barcode with phone, updates count. Weird but works.

Germany: no same-day culture. 2-3 day is standard. I keep 1 month of spares for anything that would take >3 days to source. That is my rule.

#15

I boot everything from network so local disk failure is "reboot, wait 90 seconds, continue working." For the few boxes that need local boot, I keep 1 spare. Inventory is a text file on my PXE server, edited with vim. Last modified 2024-03. I should check that.

Network boot believer because I saw too many "spare" drives that were already dead. If you do not test your spare, you have a decorative paperweight.

boot anything, anywhere, anytime
#16
PetraSuper said:
If you do not test your spare, you have a decorative paperweight

This. I bought 10 "spare" drives from a deal, 4 DOA, 2 failed within month. My $1/GB/yr rule does not apply to spares, I pay more for known-good from B&H or Adorama. Miami = no local tech suppliers, everything ships from NJ or CA.

I use a Google Sheet with conditional formatting, red when last test >90 days. Not automated but visual. I test quarterly, write date on drive with sharpie. Low tech, works.

world record: 4min Arch install
6 #17

I am in Bangalore. Local market SP Road has everything same-day but 50% is fake or refurbished sold as new. I learned to check firmware versions. Inventory is mental, I know every shopkeeper by name. Not scalable, not recommendable, but it is what I have.

For real enterprise stuff I use Dell India, 2 week lead time. Keep 2 spares minimum, hide them from my own team or they "borrow" permanently.

#18

Zurich perspective: everything is expensive, everything is slow. I use Digitec for consumer, Brack for pro, both next-day if you pay. I do not keep large spares inventory, I keep IPv4 addresses that appreciate faster than SSDs depreciate. Different risk model.

For the actual thread question: I use a self-hosted GLPI. Overkill? Yes. But Swiss compliance documentation requires traceability, so I have traceability.

/24 for sale. No lowballs.
#19

I am in Istanbul. Same-day exists for phones, not for server parts. I use Hepsiburada and Trendyol for cables, small things. For disks I have a contact in Germany who ships DHL, 3-4 days.

My inventory system: I take photo of each spare with phone, upload to private Telegram channel, search by scrolling. It is bad. This thread made me feel better about myself, thank you all.

8 #20

Following this thread. I am in Nairobi, no local server parts market to speak of. Everything comes from Dubai or China, 2-3 weeks. I keep 3 month buffer, cannot afford downtime. Spreadsheet, no automation, I check weekly like a ritual.

Chen your 4 hour drive sounds like luxury to me. At least you have a city.

Thread closed

Replies are closed on this thread. Closed: resolved.