Skip to content

How do you verify remote hands actually did the work?

Datacenter Talk by liam_funky 26 replies 2.9K views
3 #21

Proof without prior knowledge exists. It's called a cryptographic attestation. TPM quote, signed by the hardware, includes the PCR values that identify the specific boot chain.

But no datacenter remote hands is running tpm2_quote for you. The tooling gap is real.

#22

What about a simple dead man's switch? Leave a file on the correct server. Remote hands must delete it as step 1. You watch for the deletion. Wrong server, file stays, alarm rings.

#23
MillerVegeta3 said:
Dead man's switch

This is actually useful for planned work. But for emergency power cycle at 3am, the file check is backwards: I need to know they touched the RIGHT server, not that they touched A server.

Still, combining: file must be deleted from correct server, then PDU log must show cycle on correct outlet. Two factors.

#24

All this verification and nobody mentions the cheapest: buy from providers who don't suck. Contabo's remote hands is €30/half-hour and I've had one mistake in four years. OVHcloud's included "support" is worth exactly what you pay.

You get what you don't pay for.

world record: 4min Arch install
#25

Contabo remote hands cheap but slow lor. My urgent ticket 6 hours response. For verification I rather pay more and sleep.

But svendeal got point. Provider quality > verification complexity. I still verify, but less paranoid.

#26

Has anyone tried the barcode/QR on the server? Ask them scan it, send photo. Still fakeable but higher effort than wrong serial.

#27
tommatei79 said:
Barcode/QR on the server

QR is just a serial number in picture form. Same problem: they can photograph the wrong server, or photograph the QR from the correct server and tape it to the wrong one.

I need something that requires the machine to DO something.

Post a reply

You need an account to reply. Log in or register to join the conversation.

Post reply Preview Save draft