Skip to content

Windows core licensing—does anyone actually count?

VPS Hosting by olya 24 replies 2.7K views
8 #11
armstrongvds said:
No SPLA involved because you're the licensee.

Important distinction: BYOL on cloud is your own compliance risk. Oracle doesn't care if your key is valid. Microsoft does, if they ever ask.

The audit chain is: Microsoft -> SPLA partner -> maybe you. With BYOL on a free tier, the chain stops at you. Still not likely, but different shape of risk.

licensing is a suggestion
3 #12
rudi3 said:
The Hosters themselves must report the CoreCount correctly and many actually do not

Twenty years and I've cleaned up three SPLA audits. Two were reporting errors, one was a reseller claiming hyperthreaded cores as physical. Microsoft wants the socket count, not what you wish the host had.

The penalty isn't criminal, it's commercial. They true up at full retail for the gap. Seen a hoster fold rather than pay.

IPv4, IRC, and irssi — fight me
#13
haroldgsm said:
They true up at full retail for the gap.

This matches what I heard from my Contabo rep. Their SPLA reporting is audited quarterly by the distributor, not just Microsoft. The reseller channel adds a layer of verification that smaller shops skip.

I asked specifically about the Munich vs Nuremberg host counts. Same reporting standard, different physical footprints.

Single mode till I die 💀
#14

Contabo Windows VPS starts at what, €8.50? That's with SPLA baked in. My Hostinger VPS with Windows was $12 but only 2 cores and they charged extra for the license separately last year.

Now I just run Debian on Hostinger and RDP from my phone if I need Windows. Not the same but my wallet recovered.

#15
prague1983 said:
Just use Debian. Skill issue.

The SkillIssue is actually that many Enterprise tools require WindowsServer and the Wine compatibility is not there yet or? I have tried running PowerShell DSC on Debian and it is actually a nightmare.

Also @jane_ffm Contabo is actually quite good for the Price but their Singapore Datacenter has actually higher WindowsPlan pricing than Nuremberg because of the SPLA regional variation or? I have seen this on their Calculator.

#16
bengait said:
My Hostinger VPS with Windows was $12 but only 2 cores and they charged extra for the license separately last year.

Same experience. Hostinger's London datacenter, Windows 2022, they split it as base VPS + license line item. Came to about £11 all in. Dropped it after three months because I needed more RAM and the step up was painful.

Now on a Contabo VDS in London, €15 with everything included. No line item games.

#17
Alexander33 said:
Now on a Contabo VDS in London, €15 with everything included.

VDS is different SKU though. You're on dedicated cores, so their SPLA math is cleaner. No contention, no "how many VMs share this physical core" headache.

My Oracle ARM thing is basically VDS behavior at VPS price. That's the whole pitch.

one small ping for man...
#18

Following.

#19
olya said:
The audit chain is: Microsoft -> SPLA partner -> maybe you.

Has anyone actually seen Microsoft reach past the partner to an end customer? Not audit, just even a questionnaire? I ran Windows SPLA instances for six years at my old job, left, company got audited two years later. Never heard from me.

#20
systemschoi said:
Has anyone actually seen Microsoft reach past the partner to an end customer?

Once. Customer had brought their own SPLA license to a colo, which is backwards — the hoster should be the licensee. Microsoft wanted to know why the end customer was reporting usage directly. Took six months to untangle.

If you're just renting a VPS, you're invisible. If you're trying to be clever with licensing structure, you might draw attention.

IPv4, IRC, and irssi — fight me

Post a reply

You need an account to reply. Log in or register to join the conversation.

Post reply Preview Save draft