Skip to content

What do you use for secrets management?

General Discussion by Chen 23 replies 2.7K views
#1

Currently using bitwarden self-hosted on vps. Can. But rotation is manual leh. Thinking of vault lor. Too heavy for personal project lah?

Share your setup can. Want to see what others doing already.

2 #2

Right then, proper answer: 1Password family plan for the important stuff, env files I definitely shouldnt commit for the rest.

Honest limits of my service here: I dont trust myself to run Vault without breaking prod at 2am. Cheers lads.

#3

Plaintext in private github repo with 2fa enabled and I sleep fine

#4

I'm curious what you ended up using for it. I've been eyeing the same Hetzner plan for a throwaway zone but haven't pulled the trigger. 253 days is a long time to keep something this fragile running without a hiccup, or maybe it died quietly.

#5

Noting that plaintext storage of credentials, even in private repositories, violates our acceptable use policy for hosted services.

For users on our platform, we recommend:
- Bitwarden or Vaultwarden for personal use
- Proper secret rotation via API where available

Repeated violations may result in account review.

— Admin

sudo make me a sandwich
#6

Plaintext? In git? You sure?

iron core, iron will
#7
Prague said:
Plaintext? In git? You sure?

Private repo, 2fa, branch protection. More secure than half the startups in sofia I worked for.

8 #8
nuyekigor said:
Private repo, 2fa, branch protection. More secure than half the startups in sofia I worked for.

I have bad news about what happens when someone gets read access. Or when GitHub has an incident. Or when you accidentally clone to a laptop that gets stolen.

Core 2 Duo era taught me: if you can cat it without a key, it's not a secret.

iron core, iron will
2 #9
admin said:
Repeated violations may result in account review.

Wah admin stepping in liao. But fair lah, their platform their rules.

I tried vaultwarden before, lighter than vault proper. Rotation still manual though. Anyone got webhook + bitwarden cli working auto?

#10
Chen said:
Anyone got webhook + bitwarden cli working auto?

I run Vaultwarden on a Hetzner box in Nuremberg. Rotation is a cron job calling the Bitwarden CLI with a service account. Not elegant, but it works.

Your "cloud" is just someone else's computer, but at least Hetzner bills in euros and doesn't surprise me.

Post a reply

You need an account to reply. Log in or register to join the conversation.

Post reply Preview Save draft