haroldgsm
Member
Grumpy Old Sysadmin
- Joined:
- May 2024
- Posts:
- 329
- From:
- Ohio, US
About time someone made a space that is not just affiliate links and "review" posts written by people who have never logged into a server.
I have been in this business for 20 years. Back when a "low end" box meant a real machine with real transit and you compiled your own kernel because the provider's template was broken. Kids these days think a NAT VPS with 128MB RAM is "hosting." Mark my words, half these fly-by-night shops will be gone by next summer and their customers will be crying on some Discord.
Still. Better here than the alternatives. I will watch and see.
IPv4, IRC, and irssi — fight me
Richard7
Member
Pentium III Enjoyer
- Joined:
- May 2024
- Posts:
- 129
- From:
- Norfolk, UK
Back when a "low end" box meant a real machine
This takes me back. I got my first real dedicated in 2009 from a little shop in Kansas City. Dual Xeon L5420, 8GB DDR2, two 250GB WD RE3 drives in software RAID 1. Cost me $49 a month and I thought I was king of the world.
They don't make them like that anymore. The hardware, I mean. Sure you can get a Ryzen 9 with NVMe for less money now, adjusted for inflation. But there was something about those old Harpertowns. You knew exactly what you were getting. No noisy neighbors because the node was your node. I ran that box for six years until the PSU finally gave up. Provider sent me the drives in a shoebox.
Good luck with the forum. I will probably lurk more than post.
SPARCstation 20, still serving HTTP
GeorgeNmp
Member
AS64512
- Joined:
- May 2024
- Posts:
- 218
- From:
- Ashburn, US
I would note that the L5420 is a Clovertown, not Harpertown. Harpertown was the X54xx series. Small correction.
On topic: manual account approval is a sound policy. The signal-to-noise ratio on hosting forums degrades rapidly without it. I would suggest also implementing IRR validation for any ASNs users claim to operate, if that becomes relevant. Too many people announce prefixes without proper route objects and then wonder why their upstream filters them.
For the networking-curious here: if you are buying cheap transit, check whether your provider supports BGP communities for traffic engineering. Even budget upstreams often support basic ones like 65535:0 for GRACEFUL_SHUTDOWN. RPKI ROAs are non-negotiable now. If your provider does not let you create them, find one that does. The days of "just announce it and hope" are over.
I am AS64512, by the way. Mostly research prefixes an
iBGP, eBGP, don't care, just peer
Carl
Member
Rack & Stack
- Joined:
- May 2024
- Posts:
- 227
- From:
- Chicago, US
Good to see a forum that remembers hardware exists.
I am mostly rack and stack. Current project is a pallet of Dell R630s I picked up from a liquidation. $45 each, dual E5-2620 v3, 64GB DDR4, no drives. Power draw at idle is about 65W, peaks around 140W under full load. Not bad for 2014 gear. I am stuffing them with used Samsung PM863a 960GB SATA SSDs, about $18 a pop if you buy ten.
For cheap colocation I have been using a place in Buffalo that does quarter racks at $180/month with 10A 120V and 1Gbps unmetered. Not going to name them since they are not on the approved list, but you can find them if you look. Just watch your power budget. Those R630s add up fast if you fill a full 10U.
Will keep an eye on the dedicated server deals section. Always looking for more pallets.
visit twice: install and decom
Carl
Member
Rack & Stack
- Joined:
- May 2024
- Posts:
- 227
- From:
- Chicago, US
Which Buffalo colo, the 10A or 20A option?
10A. The 20A is $320 and I do not need it yet. I am running four R630s in a quarter rack right now, total draw around 280W at the meter after PDU loss. Leaves me headroom for a switch and maybe one more box if I am careful.
The 10A circuit is 120V not 208V, so you are capped at ~1200W usable. Fine for older DDR4 gear, but if you are bringing EPYC or anything with GPUs forget it. They also offer 208V but only on full racks and the price jumps.
I should mention their remote hands is $75/hour with a one hour minimum. I have only needed it once when an SSD backplane cable came loose in shipping. Cheaper than a train ticket but still annoying.
visit twice: install and decom
haroldgsm
Member
Grumpy Old Sysadmin
- Joined:
- May 2024
- Posts:
- 329
- From:
- Ohio, US
I am running four R630s in a quarter rack right now, total draw around 280W at the meter after PDU loss.
You are throwing good money after bad. Those v3s are already on the wrong side of the efficiency curve and the PM863a is read-intensive TLC with no power-loss protection worth mentioning. I have seen that exact drive fail in spectacular ways under sustained write.
But what do I know, I am just a grumpy old man who remembers when "enterprise" meant something. Enjoy your space heater collection.
IPv4, IRC, and irssi — fight me
Carl
Member
Rack & Stack
- Joined:
- May 2024
- Posts:
- 227
- From:
- Chicago, US
Those v3s are already on the wrong side of the efficiency curve
They idle at 65W for a full chassis with two CPUs, 64GB, and fans. Show me a newer platform that beats that at $45 all-in. A single Ryzen 5000 board costs more than three of these complete.
The PM863a is rated at 1.3 DWPD for five years. I am not running a database, I am running stateless containers and a backup target. Read-intensive is exactly what I need. Power-loss protection is handled by the RAID controller's cache backup, which I did not mention because it is obvious to anyone who has actually deployed this stuff.
You want to spend $800 on a NUC, be my guest. I will keep my space heaters.
visit twice: install and decom