Skip to content

Location matters less than ever, CDN made my Singapore VPS feel local

VPS Hosting by factorvet 6 replies 539 views
#1

I feel you if you're still obsessively pinging Frankfurt from Ohio. Used to matter, right? I moved my WordPress from a CloudCone EU box to their Singapore POP and added Vultr's edge layer. Site loads same speed for my US visitors. I know, I know, have you tried measuring TTFB vs full page load? I did. The difference is noise now. But I want to hear from people actually running game servers or tick-sensitive stuff. Does location still matter for you, or am I missing an edge case?

#2
factorvet said:
Does location still matter for you
  • Location absolutely matters for some things
  • But you said CDN which only helps static content
  • Dynamic requests still travel
  • My API on RackNerd Amsterdam to EU users is 280ms and that's not fixable with edge caching
  • Game servers are different
  • You can't cache player position through a POP
  • Your take works for blogs
  • Not for everything
#3

My Leaseweb SG box: 2x480GB Intel S4510, RAID-1, 95K IOPS read. Same plan in Amsterdam: 2x960GB S4610, 130K IOPS. Network latency is one metric. Disk latency another. For database workloads, both matter. CDN does nothing for your random 4K writes.

#4
Fio Disk Speed Tests (Mixed R/W 50/50):
---------------------------------
Block Size | 4k            (IOPS) | 64k           (IOPS)
  ------   | ---            ----  | ----           ----
Read       | 12.34 MB/s    (3.0k) | 198.50 MB/s   (3.1k)
Write      | 12.36 MB/s    (3.0k) | 199.40 MB/s   (3.1k)
---------------------------------
iperf3 Network Speed Tests:
---------------------------------
Provider    | Location        | Send Speed      | Recv Speed
Clouvider   | London          | 895 Mbits/sec   | 912 Mbits/sec
Wifx        | Paris           | 234 Mbits/sec   | 241 Mbits/sec

Decent disk IO, meh network. Paris to Singapore: 234 down. Same provider London: 895. Location matters for bandwidth consistency, not just latency. Numbers don't lie.

fio, iperf, geekbench. results or gtfo.
#5

In my country many users still on 3G. CDN helps but origin connection quality matters. @factorvet Your Singapore VPS, what upstream provider? Some routes from VN to SG go through Hong Kong first. Extra 40ms. Not all POPs equal. You test from multiple locations or just US?

I usually check routes on https://bgp.tools

phở at 3AM, deploy at 4
#6

IMO you're both right. CDN absolutely helps for content delivery, YMMV on dynamic workloads. Take it with a grain of salt, but I split compute and delivery: origin in cheap location, cache at edge. Best of both. Not everyone needs this complexity though. For personal projects, single box anywhere works fine. For SaaS with global users, separation helps. No strong feelings either way.

...
#7

What's the price diff on that Leaseweb plan between regions

Vive la résistance... électrique

Post a reply

You need an account to reply. Log in or register to join the conversation.

Post reply Preview Save draft