Skip to content

'Green hosting' badges are mostly marketing fiction

Reviews by SingaporeRep 4 replies 199 views
#1

I got curious after seeing three "100% renewable" providers in a row. Ran yabs on five boxes, then traced their ASN to actual datacenter locations.

Provider A: Amsterdam, NIKHEF - grid mix 78% gas (2024)
Provider B: Falkenstein, Hetzner DC - 61% lignite region
Provider C: Singapore, Hetzner DC - 95% gas
Provider D: Singapore, Keppel - 95% gas
Provider E: Oregon, Flexential - 62% hydro, 38% coal

None matched their badge claims. Two had "RECs" from wind farms 2000km away. One had a certificate from 2019, expired.

Disk: 1.2 GB/s | Net: 890 Mbps | Price: $6/mo
Disk: 890 MB/s  | Net: 410 Mbps | Price: $8/mo

Decent disk IO, meh network

If anyone has actual PPA contracts or on-site solar, post the utility bill. Otherwise it's fiction.

fio, iperf, geekbench. results or gtfo.
#2

Sir, I am running VPS with OVHcloud in Singapore. They show badge but I never check sir. Made test last month, network to Singapore is good. Thank you very much sir for doing this work, I learn much from your benchmark.

traffic worse than my packet loss
#3

SingaporeRep is the man! We make a test in brazil, is very good to see real numbers

My provider InterServer has the green leaf, but now I am thinking... maybe is fake? They charge more for "eco plan" — https://www.interserver.net

I will ask them, if they not answer I change to other, is very good thread sir

ping so high I wave back
#4

Sir SingaporeRep, thank you for this post, very helpful lah. I use Vultr in Singapore, they also have green badge but can be fake-fake one. Their support say "we buy credit" but cannot show me paper. I ask slow-slow they still no give. Wkwkwk.

I think better to look at power usage directly, not just badge. Thank you thank you.

wrap it, ship it, pray it
11 #5

I am not trusting The Google Cloud when They say carbon neutral. The Microsoft also claims this. I am using HostHatch and They have no badge at all, maybe The Honesty is better than The Fiction.

Never saw a provider show The Actual Generator Invoice.

Post a reply

You need an account to reply. Log in or register to join the conversation.

Post reply Preview Save draft