Skip to content

Forum search is worse than Google

General Discussion by MARIA3 7 replies 600 views
#1

I try to make search before post new thread. But search here not find my old thread from June about make a server up with ARM. Google find in 2 seconds with site:example.com. Forum search say "no results". Regards.

siesta first, deploy later
#2

This is insane value for frustration! The ARM thread you mean is the one on Ampere Altra, right? I remember because I posted benchmarks there! The search here really does run circles around nothing!

#3

Per my earlier writeup above in my analysis of forum UX patterns (see my 2024 meta-thread on information retrieval in low-traffic communities, section 3.2, "The Google Paradox"), the fundamental issue is threefold:

1. Index latency
- The forum search index appears to update on a weekly batch cycle rather than real-time
- Contrast with Google's continuous crawl

2. Query parsing
- No stemming ("server" vs "servers" fails)
- No synonym expansion ("hosting" vs "VPS")

3. Result ranking
- Pure chronological rather than relevance-weighted
- As I mentioned above, this penalizes high-value older posts

I have prepared a table of contents for a proposed rebuild using Elasticsearch. Who should I contact?

#4

Anyway I tried something at 3am

$ grep -r "arm ampere" /var/forum/posts/ | head

Took 800ms. Idk why I do this. The search box is just a skin over... nothing?

builds at 3AM, sleeps at noon
7 #5

SWEdish patience RUNNING out. I tried to fika my way through this but "hösting" search gives 404 on my own threads. Umlauts broken too. "fika" as verb = mandatory break, which this search needs.

#6

🚫 = mas tipo google works so we good? Anyway vale I guess

#7

Same. I just use site:example.com now

#8

Weekly batch cycle? Where did you get that number

Post a reply

You need an account to reply. Log in or register to join the conversation.

Post reply Preview Save draft